Posted: Jun 10, 2016
| Year: | Player: | School: |
| 2021-22 | Ed Wright II | MidAmerican Nazarene |
| Cedric Rollerson | Sterling College | |
| Scottie Turner | Clark University | |
| Hayden Hermreck | Ottawa University | |
| Cory Reynolds | Trevecca Nazarene University | |
| 2019-20 | Malik Hardmon | Alcorn State University/Quincy University |
| Joel Boyce | Newman University | |
| Tyus Jeffries | Kansas Wesleyan University | |
| Canaan Daniels | Southwestern College, KS | |
| 2018-19 | Perry Carroll | Fort Hays State University/Ottawa University |
| Jamaal Clifton | Tiffin University/Langston University | |
| Wesley Anderson Jr | Harris-Stowe State University | |
| 2017-18 | Tyler Williams | Southern Nazarene University |
| Jordan Marshall | Chowan University/Randall University | |
| Jacob Patterson | Arkansas Tech University | |
| Ahmad Winston | Robert Morris University | |
| Cole Silsby | Baker University | |
| Cordy Winston | University of the Ozarks | |
| 2016-17 | DaRon Mims | Angelo State University |
| Quentin Blaue | Upper Iowa University | |
| Jah-Kobe Womack | Quincy University | |
|
|
EJ Garnes | Friends University |
| Ithello Cross | Kansas Wesleyan University | |
| Beau Shockley | Multnomah University | |
|
2015-2016 |
||
| Jermaine Long | East Tennessee State University | |
| Darnell Jones-Bowie | Southern Arkansas University | |
| Jameel Henson | Southwestern College, KS | |
| Darius Redrick | Multnomah University | |
| 2014-2015 | ||
| Courtney Stockard | St. Bonaventure University, NY | |
| Josh Sweet | University of Nebraska-Kearney | |
| John Cornett | Wayland Baptist University | |
| Jordan Nanton | New York Institute of Technology | |
| 2013-2014 | ||
| Tray Fountain | Oklahoma Wesleyan University | |
| 2012-2013 | ||
| Cameron Blue | University of Arkansas Monticello | |
| Andrew Rountree | Langston University | |
| 2011-2012 | ||
| Canon Fields | Kansas Wesleyan University | |
| Terrell Shears | University of Southern Arkansas | |
| 2006-2007 | ||
| Elias Yeadon | University of Mobile, AL | |
| Trumaine Pearson | Georgia Southern University, GA | |
| 2005-2006 | ||
| Brad Clincy | Lewis and Clark State University, ID | |
| Brian Curtis | Portland State University, OR | |
| Jermaine Harris | Northeastern State University, OK | |
| Terrence Gamble | Tarleton State University, TX | |
| 2004-2005 | ||
| Darren Jefferies | University of Northern Colorado, CO | |
| Guy Falkenhagen | Bemidji State University, MN | |
| Levi Huncovsky | American University, MA | |
| Lawrence Oeding | Mayville State University, ND | |
| 2003-2004 | ||
| Musa Kamara | University of Minnesota, MN | |
| Robert Cox | Utah State University, UT | |
| Eric Waterman | Southwestern College, KS | |
| Andrew Washington | University of Delaware, DE | |
| Antoine Tisby | University of South Carolina, SC |